◆ AfterJournal
Author guidelines · Contact
Business 19 Nov 2026

The Russell 2000 Closed Two Points From a Death Cross on Nov 17

On Nov 17 the Russell 2000 closed two points from a death cross. This lays out what the crossover is, what followed earlier S&P 500 and Russell 2000 crosses, why the signal lags the drop, and how rebalancing and switching costs fit into an index fund plan.

The Russell 2000 Closed Two Points From a Death Cross on Nov 17

On Nov 17, 2026 the Russell 2000 closed at 2,702. That was below both its 50-day moving average of about 2,815 and its 200-day of 2,813, according to The Trading Tools newsletter, and the two averages were two points apart. A death cross is the day the 50-day line drops below the 200-day line. It means recent prices have been weaker than the longer trend.

Two lines, two points apart

A 50-day moving average is the average of the last 50 daily closes. Each new session adds one close and drops the oldest. The 200-day line does the same thing over 200 closes, so it moves more slowly.

The newsletter's author was careful about timing: "The cross has not printed yet, but the arithmetic is nearly settled." If it does print, it would be the Russell 2000's first death cross since March 2025. The same author counts 28 earlier ones going back to 1988.

Crosses also reverse. A MarketWatch piece republished on iTiger cites Dow Jones Market Data dating a Russell 2000 cross to Oct 13, 2023, with the index out of it again by Dec 29, 2023.

What the S&P 500 did after earlier crosses

The large-cap index has the longer paper trail. Tradermarkus counted 27 S&P 500 death crosses from 1971 to 2025 and compared what came after each one with the return from any day. Twelve months on, the median gain after a cross was 11.4%. From any day, the median was 11.1%.

Going back to 1950, Schaeffer's Investment Research found 34 signals in an analysis published on Investing.com. It reports averages, not medians. One month after a cross the index was down 0.89% on average and higher less than half the time, the only negative figure in this set. The six-month average was 3.69% and the 12-month average 4.52%.

Positive average returns at 3, 6 and 12 months show up in LPL Financial's work, as reported by Yahoo Finance, "with a 72% win rate 12 months after the signal."

S&P 500 after a death cross (row labels say median or average)1 month3 months12 months
Tradermarkus, median return (27 crosses)+1.8%+4.5%+11.4%
Tradermarkus, share of crosses followed by a gain56%67%74% (20 of 27)
Schaeffer's, average return (34 signals)Down 0.89%, higher less than half the timeNot reported+4.52%
LPL, average returnNot reportedPositive, no figure givenPositive, 72% win rate
AssumptionsIndex: S&P 500 only. Tradermarkus covers 1971 to 2025 and reports medians. Schaeffer's covers 1950 onward and reports averages. LPL reports averages and its period is not stated. Only Tradermarkus compares crosses with any day, and only at 12 months: a median of +11.1% from any day. None of the sources says whether dividends are included. Index returns, before fund fees and tax.

The one-month figures split. Tradermarkus has the index higher after 56% of crosses, with a median gain of 1.8%, while Schaeffer's has it higher less than half the time and down 0.89% on average. At 12 months, the Schaeffer's average of 4.52% sits well below the Tradermarkus median of 11.4%. The two cover different years and report different measures.

Six of the last seven S&P death crosses were followed by positive one-year returns, Schaeffer's adds. The exception was December 2007. LPL's Turnquist reads the signal as a warning: death crosses "indicate recent price action is losing momentum and can serve as a prescient warning sign for developing downside risk."

MarketWatch's Kilgore, in the piece republished on iTiger, puts the timing question this way: a death cross "isn't seen as much of a market-timing tool, as they tend to be telegraphed."

A trader seen from behind on an exchange floor, looking up at a bank of screens showing index charts
A trader seen from behind on an exchange floor, looking up at a bank of screens showing index charts - Photo: Pexels

Late by design, and the shorter Russell record

Both lines are built from past closes. A moving average works like a Winnipeg heating bill: an accurate record of the cold snap, delivered after it is over. Tradermarkus calls the cross "late by design" and puts a figure on it: on the day of an S&P 500 cross, the index was a median 8.5% below its 12-month high.

The worst outcomes in the Tradermarkus set followed the 2000 and 2007 crosses, when the index fell by up to 30.9% and 49.3% within a year.

Less of the small-cap record is public. A 2015 Schaeffer's study of the Russell 2000 put the average three-month gain after a cross at 2.6%, the same as from any day, with the index higher 69% of the time three months after a signal against 64% from any day, and an average one-week gain of 0.02%. When the March 2025 cross arrived, Dow Jones Market Data showed that near-term performance after Russell crosses had been weak, while the index "fared better over the longer term." MoneyWeek's finding of "no statistically significant difference" covers death crosses since 1990, and it flags a false signal in Oct 2005, in the middle of a bull market.

Breadth, and what is still open

Breadth counts how many stocks in an index are joining a move, usually rising stocks against falling ones. None of the studies cited here tests whether a cross with weak breadth has been followed by worse returns than a cross alone, so what breadth adds to the signal is not known. Also unknown are whether the Russell 2000 cross printed after Nov 17 and how a Canadian small-cap index has fared after crosses, since every study here covers US indexes. The Trading Tools keeps its return figures for the 28 earlier Russell crosses behind a paywall, and the MarketWatch report on the current crossover was not available at the time of writing.

Rebalancing and the cost of switching

A rebalancing rule, set on a calendar or at bands around a target weight, buys whatever has fallen below its target, with or without a crossover. On time horizon, every 12-month figure in the S&P table is positive.

In Canada, switching funds inside a TFSA or RRSP triggers no tax, while selling a fund in a non-registered account realizes a capital gain or loss for the year. The US works the same way: trades inside an IRA or an employer retirement plan are not taxed, while gains in a taxable brokerage account are. Every trade also pays the bid-ask spread, once on the way out and again on the way back in, and the signal behind the trade is one Tradermarkus calls "late by design."

If it were my money, a small-cap index plan built to run for years would stay as it is.

Kevin Marchand
Written by

Kevin Marchand

For eleven years, Kevin kept the books for his parents' flooring store in Winnipeg. That's where he learned to read every invoice twice. Now he writes about money: budgets, mortgages, small business costs and what a rais...

View profile

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a Comment

◆ Newsletter

Ideas worth your inbox.

The best new stories, startups and AI tools every week. No noise, unsubscribe anytime.